top of page
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

RECOVERING WOMEN’S VOICES IN ANCIENT INDIA

3 hours ago
5 min read
IMAGE CREDITS- INSTAGRAM
IMAGE CREDITS- INSTAGRAM

Can a history, often interpreted through the lens of patriarchy, offer an alternative history of women's autonomy and agency? This becomes a particularly interesting question in the context of ancient India, which is often discussed through the narratives of women's subordination, thereby leaving less room to examine instances of women exercising intellectual agency and asserting their choice, challenging the social structure of the time. It is this challenging task of reinterpreting ancient Indian history through a feminist lens that Mukul Kumar undertakes in his book ‘Women in the Womb of Time: Unveiling Ancient Feminism.’ Through this approach, he reimagines power, authority, and participation from a renewed perspective. He challenges the historical exclusion of women’s voices from the dominant narratives of political thought and history, thereby reclaiming women’s position as political subjects. It makes us think of politics beyond the dimensions of the public and private domains to a more integral one, where women play a significant role in redefining politics by focusing on the nuances of daily routine.

Feminism is undoubtedly one of the most significant ideas that has captured the imagination of writers from time immemorial. These days, there have been multiple attempts to retell ancient history from a feminist perspective. In a similar way to fictional reinterpretations, Kumar's book offers a fact-based, non-fictional effort to bring ancient Indian feminism to light. Through a simple, empirical, yet balanced approach, Kumar engages with the otherwise complex question of feminism in ancient India, while recognising the difficulty of looking at the past from a modern standpoint. 

The author is a civil servant, a novelist, and a poet. He has been involved in writing about contemporary topics, such as Life, freedom, and love. His earlier writings, Lost in the Love Maze, Seduction by Truth, and As Boys Become Men, showcase his approach of carving out the complexities of adulthood through stories for readers. In this book, Kumar goes even further, excavating the notion of feminism from the womb of ancient India.

The choice of vocabulary for the title of the book clearly signifies the author's attempt to bring out from "the womb of time" the pro-feminist voices of the past, which have often been overlooked, thereby attaching a perfect metaphor of the womb to symbolise the recovery of these forgotten voices. The book is divided into ten chapters, and the author follows a chronological order in presenting the stories from the Vedic period to the Heterodox Indian traditions, accompanied by epigraphic and numismatic evidence to decipher women's voices from the past. Besides the introductory and the concluding chapter, there are eight chapters dedicated to a specific chronological theme starting from the Vedas, the Epics, the Manu Smriti, the Arthashastra, the Kamasutra, the Dharmashastra, the Smritis, and heterodox Indian traditions to the epigraphic and numismatic study of female power.  Each chapter contains the corresponding shlokas from representative texts of the period, thus grounding his arguments in empirical evidence and anecdotes. Through each chapter, Kumar unfolds debates on ancient feminism, mentioning concerns of earlier thinkers and historians, and extends the debate by presenting a fresh perspective on the particular text, or, as in the last chapter, new archaeological evidence coming to light. 

One of the most noteworthy aspects of the book is the balance it maintains between engaging with the works of pioneering historians, thinkers, and novelists, such as Wendy Doniger, Kumkum Roy, Uma Chakraborty, Chitra Banerjee, and Devdutta Patnaik, while drawing extensively on primary sources of the Vedas, Epics, Dharmasutras, and Dharmashastras, along with coins, inscriptions, and sculptures, thereby offering empirical evidence for the present-day discourse. What is striking is that he does not try to fulfill his objective of revealing instances of women's autonomy through familiar accounts of Draupadi, Savitri, or Sita; instead, he takes on the difficult task of going beyond these obvious and well-known figures to bring back women who have often been sidelined in popular narratives, such as Urvashi, Tara, Surpanakha, Mandodari, and Kunti. The author offers a modern vigour through these characters, who demystify intricate women's choices and decisions within a patriarchal setup. His idea is to make the reader recognise the strength these women possessed through their fierce will to defy the prevailing expectations for women of the time. 

The book also makes an active effort to reconnect past experiences with contemporary concerns of property ownership, widow remarriage, and institutional responses to crime against women.  For instance, in the chapter on the Vedas, he cites Rigvedic shlokas that discuss widow remarriage. Similarly, he brings out excerpts from the Arthashastra to describe punishments for sexual assault, domestic abuse, and financial fraud. By doing so, he offers an alternative understanding of ancient India by bringing historical experiences into conversation with debates that continue to shape the present. Striking a measured tone, neither excessive glorification of antiquity nor feminist criticism, the book advocates a critical reading of the texts to bring forth ideas hidden deep within them that would not be possible through a cursory reading. Therefore, by giving examples from archaeological sources, such as women's independent philanthropic contributions, such as garden tanks and temple endowments, he encourages readers and further researchers to reevaluate the condition of women in ancient India. 

Overall, Kumar's writing style is simple and conversational, yet he maintains the necessary scholarly tone. The language is very clear and crisp, and the author explains ancient terms from shlokas without compromising the accuracy of the arguments. This definitely makes the book quite appropriate for students, researchers, teachers, and general readers who are looking for a novel way to engage with ancient feminist discourse. Though the book manages to cover the topic comprehensively and in a way that's not too difficult for the general audience, it can't do away with the fictional tone in a few places. Moreover, one can raise a concern that these instances of women’s autonomy might be the reality of only a few and didn't translate in a similar manner in the broader lives of ordinary women, raising a doubt about whether the textual representation of women's autonomy actually translates into lived realities.

Despite these concerns, the book is accessible and engaging, maintaining clarity in its arguments and proving helpful, particularly for individuals who may have apprehensions about feminism as an intricate domain. By locating the analysis of ancient feminism within the framework of deep textual and archaeological affirmations, Kumar transforms his work into a resource for thoughtful engagement with contemporary feminist debates.


By Maham Ismail and Bhavana

Maham Ismail is a Research Scholar pursuing a PhD in Political Science under the supervision of Professor Himanshu Prasad Roy, from the Centre for Political Studies (CPS), Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU), New Delhi. Her research examines gendered welfare politics and state–society relations in India, with particular attention to women’s experiences of welfare, dignity, autonomy and everyday encounters with the state.


Bhavana is pursuing PhD in Political Studies (III Semester) under supervision of Dr. Preeti Dahiya from Centre for Political Studies (CPS), Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU), New Delhi. She also worked as an Assistant Professor on contract basis at RIE, NCERT, Ajmer (2021 – 2024). Her Research contributions include working as Field Investigator for National Evaluation of Kasturba Gandhi Balika Vidyalaya, project conducted by NCERT, MoE (2022) and presenting a paper titled Cyber Laws Governing Online World in India, at national seminar on Population Education at RIE. The paper is published in journal Educational Trend, Volume 5, Issue 2, July 2024 (ISSN: 2583-6269).

REFERENCES-

Kumar, M. (2026). Women in the Womb of Time: Unveiling Ancient Feminism. BluOneInk Pvt. Ltd.


Comments


bottom of page